• Wed. Nov 29th, 2023

    Critical Thought

    Critical thoughts on quantum technologies

    A New Approach to Risk Aggregation: Quantum Copulas

    ByThemba Hadebe

    Nov 11, 2023
    A New Approach to Risk Aggregation: Quantum Copulas


    Risk aggregation is a critical task in various fields, from finance to healthcare. Traditionally, linear correlation has been used to analyze the relationship between variables. However, this approach has its limitations, particularly when dealing with non-normal distributions. Copulas, on the other hand, offer a more nuanced representation of dependence beyond linearity and normality.

    In risk management, understanding dependence is crucial for assessing undiversifiable risks. Copulas allow for modeling the joint distribution of random variables by estimating their marginal distributions and dependence structure separately. This flexibility is especially valuable in building multivariate risk models, where the behavior of individual risk factors may be better understood than their dependence structure. Copulas are widely used in various applications, including credit risk modeling and derivatives pricing.

    While bivariate copulas have been extensively studied, constructing copulas in higher dimensions is a more challenging task. Existing classes of copulas have their limitations. Archimedean copulas lack flexibility, vine copulas can be prone to overfitting, and elliptical copulas assume a specific dependence structure. In this paper, we present a data-driven quantum method that offers a higher degree of modeling flexibility without making assumptions about the parametric forms of the dependence structure.

    Quantum Copulas

    Building on machine learning approaches to copulas, recent studies have shown that generative learning algorithms on trapped ion quantum computers can outperform classical models in terms of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test. Specifically, a Quantum Circuit Born Machine (QCBM) trained on historical returns of individual stocks was able to generate joint distributions with higher accuracy than equivalent classical models.

    While previous work focused on two-variable copulas, we aim to explore the scalability and practical potential of quantum copulas with a higher number of variables. In this study, we apply a QCBM-based approach to model 3- and 4-variable copulas on trapped ion quantum computers. We analyze the training process and compare the results with standard classical models.

    Training Challenges and Solutions

    As the number of variables increases, the complexity of parameter optimization in the training process also increases. We observe decreased training efficacy when scaling up the models. To address this challenge, we introduce an annealing-inspired strategy that dramatically improves the training results. This strategy allows us to achieve comparable or better predictions in risk aggregation tasks compared to traditional classical models.


    The discovery of quantum copulas offers a new approach to risk aggregation. By leveraging the power of trapped ion quantum computers, we can model joint distributions more accurately and efficiently. While there are still challenges to overcome in terms of scalability, the promising results of this study indicate the potential of quantum copulas in real-world applications. Further research and development in this field will unlock the full practical potential of quantum algorithms for risk analysis and decision-making.

    Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

    Q: What are copulas?

    A: Copulas are mathematical tools used for modeling joint probability distributions.

    Q: What is the advantage of using copulas over linear correlation?

    A: Copulas offer a richer representation of dependence beyond linearity and normality, making them more suitable for analyzing non-normal distributions.

    Q: How are copulas used in risk management?

    A: Copulas are used to model the joint distribution of risk factors, allowing for a more accurate assessment of undiversifiable risks. This information is crucial for risk-based capital reserves and derivatives pricing.

    Q: What challenges do quantum copulas face?

    A: Scaling up quantum copulas to a higher number of variables poses challenges in terms of parameter optimization. However, an annealing-inspired strategy has shown promising results in addressing this challenge.

    Q: What is the potential of quantum copulas in real-world applications?

    A: Quantum copulas have the potential to provide more accurate and efficient risk aggregation in various fields, including finance, healthcare, and climate analysis.